HUDDERSFIELD, ENGLAND - SEPTEMBER 24: Kalvin Phillips of Manchester City during the Carabao Cup Third Round match between Huddersfield Town and Manchester City at Accu Stadium on September 24, 2025 in Huddersfield, England. (Photo by Robbie Jay Barratt - AMA/Getty Images)
Leeds United supporters, as well as every other fanbase, haven’t been able to stop talking about the bombshell announcement regarding Manchester City being found guilty of financial breaches.
LeedsAllOver’s Kris Smith was recently on The Overlap’s Fan Debate. Whilst on it, he shared his thoughts on the matter when asked by Jamie Carragher.
A possible sanction for Man City is unknown at this stage. But talkSPORT presenter Alan Brazil claims that multiple sources have told him that Man City could be facing a 60-point deduction.
But regardless of what their punishment ends up being if their appeal fails, I can’t help but think about one former Leeds United hero. He has indirectly been caught up in all of this.
Man City guilty verdict will surely make Kalvin Phillips regret the move even more
Back in 2022, as England’s best holding midfielder, Kalvin Phillips made the £45million move from Leeds to Man City.
We know it never truly worked out for our academy graduate. Phillips found game time hard to come by under Pep Guardiola. The Englishman was also loaned out to the likes of West Ham and Ipswich.
Now the midfielder is in the midst of his second loan spell at Sheffield United.
During his stint at Man City, Phillips won two Premier League titles, a Champions League, a FA Cup, League Cup, Super Cup, Club World Cup and a Community Shield. (Transfermarkt)
But despite having a full trophy cabinet, all of his winner’s medals have come with an asterisk. That asterisk being that he barely played and didn’t contribute significantly to any of them.
Whilst the charges Man City have been found guilty of span between 2009 and 2018, all of their success that has come in the aftermath has been built on a foundation of cheating if they do not win their appeal.
So now, Phillips’ medals have another massive asterisk alongside them. Surely the midfielder will be regretting his decision to move across the Pennines even more now.
Kalvin Phillips should’ve moved elsewhere if he was going to leave Leeds
Even if Phillips stayed in 2022, we were so poor that we would’ve likely been relegated anyway in 2023. But I suppose we’ll never know.
But if Phillips ended up leaving in 2022 or even in the aftermath of our relegation in 2023, I’m sure he wishes he moved elsewhere.
He was never going to start ahead of Rodri. However, I thought there would be plenty of chances for Phillips to get games at Man City when considering how deep they typically go in all competitions.
However, this turned out to not be the case, and Guardiola seriously mismanaged him.
If Phillips got his move right after leaving Leeds, there’s every chance he’d have still been in the England squad. It’s easy to forget just how good he was for us.
But at 30, in what should be the prime years of his career, he’s back in the Championship.
The midfielder left his boyhood club where he was adored and on track to reach legend status. Phillips chose to ditch that in favour of moving to Man City.
His reward? Medals that could potentially be some of the most illegitimate in the history of English football.
So whether he wishes he moved elsewhere or ultimately just stuck things out at Elland Road, Phillips will know deep down that his move to Man City in 2022 was a huge mistake.
So,so sad!