“For me…” – Shearer, Hart in agreement on MOTD over Chelsea v Leeds United flashpoint
Leeds United made it back-to-back wins in the Premier League yesterday.
Noah Okafor’s winner against Spurs ensured we entered the international break on a high, and the Swiss winger was integral as we thrashed Chelsea 4-1 at Stamford Bridge.
Okafor’s two goals, alongside a Dominic Calvert-Lewin penalty and a Brenden Aaronson strike, were enough to secure our first Premier League win at Stamford Bridge since 1999.
However, when the game was at 1-1, United were awarded a penalty. Alan Shearer and Joe Hart analysed the contentious incident on Match of the Day.
Joe Hart and Alan Shearer disagree with Leeds’ penalty
Okafor’s first goal of the afternoon cancelled out Emmanuel Emegha’s opener for Chelsea and ensured we went into the break level.
However, we came straight out of the traps in the second half and piled the pressure on Chelsea.
Jayden Bogle unleashed a powerful half-volley from the edge of the box that was headed towards goal. However, it was blocked by Morgan Rogers before it could test Emi Martinez in the Chelsea goal.
Michael Oliver pointed straight to the spot, and after a lengthy VAR check, the decision stood. Calvert-Lewin would convert the penalty as Leeds ran riot. Okafor and Aaronson’s subsequent goals ensured we returned to West Yorkshire with all three points.
But the penalty shout was a major turning point in the second half. Former Manchester City goalkeeper Hart isn’t sure it was a penalty to begin with.
“The key in this is that Michael Oliver gives the penalty originally. It’s a really, really difficult one. It’s hard for us to decide whether it is or whether it isn’t (a penalty),” Hart said.
“Bogle’s strike hits Rogers, and Michael Oliver immediately takes the decision; he thinks it’s a penalty. I’ve got no problems with that, but when it goes to the VAR, for them to intervene, they’ve got to prove it definitely isn’t.
“As we see the replays, it’s tough; I don’t think Rogers makes himself any bigger. I’m not sure whether it hit him below the badge on the arm, which is the tipping point.
“I just wish Michael Oliver would’ve been given the opportunity to see that again because he made the decision at such a pace, at 1-1, it was such a big decision. I’m not sure he got the right one.”
Shearer then briefly shared his thoughts, saying, “It’s not a penalty for me.”
Leeds were in the ascendancy regardless of the penalty
Regardless of whether we were awarded a penalty, in that second half, it seemed inevitable we would score at some stage with how firmly we were knocking on the door of the Chelsea defence.
And with the way we were playing, nobody could have had any complaints with us leading.
For me, the replays are so poor that it makes it hard to come to a definitive judgement one way or the other.
However, it wasn’t long ago that Calvert-Lewin had a goal ruled out against Bournemouth for a harsh handball
So whilst it definitely was debatable, these are the type of decisions that even their way out over the course of the season.
But we shouldn’t let it distract us from what was an incredible display from the Whites on the road.